The Three Characteristics of Existence and Family Business Management

In an article titled "Dharma and Family Business" published in the June issue of the Finance and Banking Journal, I wrote about "The Goal of Family Business: Wealth or Sustainability towards ESG." In that article, I applied three Buddhist principles—the Four Principles of Social Harmony (Sanghahavatthu 4), the Seven Virtues of a Good Person (Sappurisadhamma 7), and the Four Sublime States of Mind (Brahma Vihara 4)—to setting family business goals. These principles also served as guidelines for managing family businesses and creating a family constitution to ensure long-term business sustainability.

I will apply the Three Characteristics of Existence—impermanence, suffering, and non-self—to the world of family businesses, business owners, and heirs, in order to truly benefit the management of family businesses. This involves preparing and planning with prudence, even if the family business ultimately cannot survive as intended.

The rise and fall of family businesses.
The Three Characteristics of Existence: A Truth You Should Know

The Buddha's teachings express the fundamental impermanence of all conditioned phenomena: "All conditioned things are impermanent; their arising leads to decay and dissolution; having arisen, they inevitably cease. The cessation of these conditioned things is emptiness; all conditioned things are subject to decay. Therefore, cultivate mindfulness and heedfulness." This principle outlines the Three Characteristics (impermanence, suffering, and non-self).

From the Buddha's teachings mentioned above, it can be assumed that no family business in the world will last forever, without collapsing or ceasing to exist. The end or extinction of a family business, which may include a change of ownership to a new owner or the business's eventual collapse, is therefore normal. No matter how great a business is, how long it has lasted for centuries, or how many generations it has been passed down, it cannot escape or avoid its eventual end according to the fundamental principles of Dharma: impermanence (anicca), suffering (dukkha), and non-self (anatta).

In his book, "The Human Manual," Venerable Buddhadasa explained that the Three Characteristics (Trilakshana) are: "The common characteristics of all things, and the truth that all conditioned things are impermanent and suffering; all phenomena are non-self; all things are suffering; all things are not self."

Therefore, the Three Characteristics of Existence clearly indicate that Buddhism is simply a discipline and practice that enables us to understand what is what. And once understood, it can be concluded that "there is nothing worth clinging to, nothing worth being." When this understanding arises, the mind ceases to desire anything, and when attachment leads to involvement, it is done with mindfulness and wisdom, not with the power of craving. Thus, there will be no suffering.

If all family business owners understood this principle, they would be free from suffering. However, in reality, this is difficult. In practice, for ordinary business owners who may not regularly practice Dharma (observing precepts, meditating), conducting business with wisdom by understanding these fundamental principles would likely reduce their suffering.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya (Payutto) did not explain the Three Characteristics (impermanence, suffering, and non-self) in the book "The Constitution of Life," but his book "Buddhadhamma" has a section where he explains this very well. Therefore, I would like to use the teachings from that section as the basis for my explanation.

He explained that the ethical values ​​of the Three Characteristics (impermanence, suffering, and non-self) are divided into two aspects: the value of cultivating the mind or the value of liberation and freedom, and the value of performing actions or the value of mindfulness, which means letting go and not being negligent.

In reality, it might be difficult for typical family business owners to practice letting go mentally. However, maintaining prudence in their business operations is likely easier for them. And if they also gain understanding and gradually learn about letting go, it will be beneficial.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya stated that suffering is the cause of the urgency in performing tasks, which is:

1. Acting out of coercion : This means taking action to resolve a problem that arises, but it may be too late (e.g., a negligent family business owner, losing awareness when a problem arises and cannot be solved in time or is impossible to solve).

2. Acting out of fear of suffering : This refers to those who are apprehensive about the possibility of suffering arriving, and therefore act to prevent decline (which often aligns with the characteristics of owners of family businesses in the succession generation, who tend to plan out of fear, such as fear of business failure, fear of losing assets and money, or fear of not having an heir). However, this is better than the first type of fear.

3. Acting with knowledge of suffering means managing it using wisdom. This involves understanding the three characteristics of existence (impermanence, suffering, non-self), recognizing change and potential problems, and using wisdom to consider the causes and factors in the change process. It relies on the impermanence (anicca) and non-self (anatta), and uses past experiences as lessons. By learning from past lessons, one can prevent suffering. (However, in reality, this is difficult and doesn't require formal spiritual learning; rather, one must continuously practice Dharma until the wisdom to solve problems arises.)

I always say that business people should practice Dharma because, ultimately, it will cultivate wisdom that can be used to solve problems and plan for family businesses. This would be most beneficial and applicable to family businesses. (See Buddhist Teachings, Volume 1, page 117)

impermanent Impermanence
For business and leaders.

The word "anicca" in Pali comes from "anicca," meaning impermanent, fleeting, arising and ceasing. The impermanence of family businesses can therefore be divided into two aspects, within the context of family businesses.

1. The Impermanence of Business: Long-standing family businesses, often those spanning three or four generations, are often those where the owners are able to accept the fleeting nature of business. Business history is full of examples of enterprises that flourished in one era but collapsed in another. Statistics show that only about 12% of a family business remains in the third generation, and only 3-4% in the fourth generation.

Despite the myth of the three-generation curse on family businesses and academic efforts to find ways or formulas to dispel this belief using knowledge of family business management, it must be acknowledged that family businesses will inevitably end at some point. Everything is impermanent; things arise and decay are inevitable, whether through loss of ownership to others or complete business collapse. The key is to prevent this from happening or to minimize its recurrence through careful planning.

In the context of Thai family businesses, we have witnessed several major shifts, from the 1997 Asian financial crisis (Tom Yum Goong crisis) and the global 2008 financial crisis (Hamburger crisis), to the advent of technology and AI, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the ongoing geopolitical shifts. Each period has demonstrated the impermanence of family businesses in different ways and at different times.

Family businesses that understand the nature of impermanence will be able to adapt more quickly because they don't "cling" to old ways. Instead, they are prepared to take preventative measures to avoid decline and damage through prudence and knowledgeable planning.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Maha Patcharayanmuni (His Eminence Somdej Acharya Chayasaro) once preached that, "Life is change, and because change instills fear in humans, they seek ways to protect themselves, to control and prevent change from occurring."

But the Buddha taught us to contemplate change, to study change, and not to become victims of change. Because Buddhism teaches that true peace arises from understanding, which must come from seeing things as they truly are. And when we see things as they truly are, one of those things is change.

He further explained that letting go is not neglect, but rather letting go within the action, meaning that whatever duty one performs, one performs it without being overwhelmed by desires. Letting go of the desires that arise during work, but it does not mean letting go of the work itself. (From the book "Retirement is Not Retirement," Panya Prateep Foundation, 2568)

This teaching can be directly applied to business if business owners understand the Three Characteristics of Existence (impermanence, suffering, and non-self). By wisely applying the concept of uncertainty without complacency, they can adapt and cope with the changes that occur.

If we were to apply the 6C formula for success, it would include Change, which means changing our mindset and working methods. This involves acting wisely, recognizing the impermanence of things, not only to prevent business decline or damage, but also to ensure the sustainability of the business.

2. The Impermanence of Leaders and Founders: A deeper challenge than business transformation is accepting the impermanence of one's own business. Because family business founders are often so deeply attached to their ventures that they are reluctant to pass them on, when the time comes to do so or when they must leave.

This is because unplanned deaths, whether related to wills, business transfers, succession planning, illness, or succession planning, along with legal documents such as wills and living wills, are crucial for prudent business owners. It is essential for family business leaders to practice mindfulness and understand the Three Characteristics of Existence (impermanence, suffering, and non-self) with caution to ensure the business's survival.

In his treatise on life's principles, Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya explained the concept of "Kalanyuta," meaning knowing the right time. In the context of family business, this refers to knowing when it's appropriate to pave the way for the next generation and when one still needs to remain in the role.

Leaders who understand the impermanence of their own position will not cling to their position and power to the point of hindering the progress of the business, but will prepare and cultivate themselves to hand over the business to the next generation.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Maha Patcharayanmuni (Venerable Ajahn Chayasaro) once answered a question in his book, "Retirement is Not Retirement," explaining that some people say retirement is a constant change in life, and that some retirees remain attached and unable to let go. Therefore, one must learn to understand that position is a mere construct, not a true self, and one must not be complacent. (See the book by Ajahn Chayasaro, "Retirement is Not Retirement," Panya Prateep Foundation, 2568).

In practice, the impermanence of leaders manifests in many forms: aging, the decline of physical and mental health, the fact that skills and experiences once valuable may become outdated in another, and decisions that were once correct may become mistakes in a changing environment. Without an understanding of impermanence, clinging to old ways is futile.

Including sudden death, which can lead to damage and the end of a family business (see C5 Complacency (negligence and lack of caution, which are causes of failure), Formula 6C Failure, pages 80-81).

To elaborate on the concept of heedfulness (appamada), Somdej Buddhaghosacharya explained in his book, "Buddhadhamma," Volume 1, page 116, that there are three points:

1. Appreciate the value and importance of every moment that passes. Use time wisely, not letting time and opportunities slip away. Use time effectively to create the greatest value and benefit.

2. Do not become intoxicated, negligent, arrogant, or careless in controlling yourself and inadvertently doing wrong or evil things.

3. Strive to create goodness and well-being; be enthusiastic and proactive; do not neglect your duties, but develop your intellect and act cautiously (do not be negligent in virtuous deeds).

While adaptable businesses are often those with flexible leaders who accept that "what used to work may not always work," those who refuse to change will fall into the 6C's of failure (including No Change Blindness, a refusal to accept change that could easily lead to the end of the family business, and the fourth C, Complacency, a lack of caution and negligence).

While business owners who “know how to let go” of outdated things and “know how to embrace” new, valuable, or changed things tend to succeed in the long run, impermanence must be addressed through change (C6 - Change), encompassing both thinking and working methods. Understanding the root causes of suffering (problems) and adapting these changes with the wisdom of family members is key to overcoming challenges.

Suffering Suffering and problems.
That's normal in business.

Suffering here doesn't just refer to direct physical pain, but also to the inherent nature of things that make us "unable to remain in the same state," inherent conflicts and imperfections, or business owners not getting what they want, businesses not meeting expectations, or conflicts arising within families or organizations.

Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya explained that, at its deepest level, suffering (dukkha) refers to "the oppression, conflict, and imperfection inherent in all conditioned phenomena."

1. The Origin of Suffering in Family Businesses : The Overlapping of Three Business Circles. Family business scholars worldwide agree that family businesses have a unique and complex characteristic due to three dimensions: Family, Business, and Ownership. Each individual in each circle has different and sometimes conflicting needs.

These are the fundamental constraints of family businesses. They are not anyone's fault (see Chapter 5, Family Business Problems and Their Solutions: The Three-Circle Family Business Theory (The Formula for Success book, pages 36-55)), but are unavoidable natural processes. Therefore, sound business decisions within the family dimension and regarding legally recognized ownership rights can destroy both relationships and the business simultaneously. Without planned communication, or the kindness and compassion outlined in the 6C formula, the business owners will suffer.

2. The Suffering of the Owner : An Invisible Burden . Owners of family businesses often bear suffering that is invisible to outsiders. Buddhadasa Bhikkhu divided suffering into two levels: "ordinary suffering," which is clearly perceptible, and "inherent suffering," which is hidden in the nature of all things. In the business context, the ordinary suffering of the owner includes financial pressure, conflicts with partners or heirs, and various crises that arise in the business. But the inherent suffering is deeper: the feeling of isolation of being a leader, the fear of losing what has been built over a lifetime, and anxiety about the future of their descendants.

3. The hardships of heirs/inheritors of family businesses: Heirs to family businesses often face unique forms of hardship. They are frequently expected to inherit a business that the founders worked so hard to build, while at the same time, they may be constantly compared to the founders.

This suffering has two sides: one is the pressure of expectations, and the other is the struggle to create one's own identity under the shadow of the founder.

In his treatise on life's principles, the Venerable Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya explained the concept of "Attaññuta," or self-knowledge, which refers to understanding one's abilities, strengths, and limitations. An heir with Attaññuta will not attempt to imitate the founder in every aspect, but will instead leverage their own abilities and vision to build upon the business in a balanced way. Suffering (Dukkha) will lessen when the heir stops trying to be someone they are not, instead finding their own strengths, aspirations, or goals and communicating them to the person who passed them on.

A common example is when heirs with business administration degrees from abroad return to find the family business being operated in a way they disagree with, while the founders retain full power. This conflict is unavoidable suffering, but it can be managed with wisdom based on the Three Characteristics of Existence – recognizing the impermanence of the situation, understanding the inherent friction, and understanding that there is no "self" to win or lose, but only a business to be jointly managed – through communication, following the 6C formula.

 

Using suffering as a lesson.

Wise reflection in problem solving.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Maha Patcharayanmuni (His Eminence Somdej Acharya Chayasaro) consistently emphasized "Yonisomanasikara," or skillful thinking, which means systematically analyzing causes and effects. He explained that those who possess Yonisomanasikara are "easily happy and less prone to suffering," and can adapt to a rapidly changing world. In the context of family businesses, Yonisomanasikara means viewing problems (suffering) with the eyes of a wise person, not with panic. For example, when family business sales are poor, instead of panicking, one systematically searches for the causes. When family conflicts arise, one doesn't harbor anger but looks for the root cause of the problem. When heirs are unwilling to inherit the business, one doesn't force them, but communicates to understand their needs and concerns.

His Holiness the Supreme Patriarch explained in the Constitution of Life that, “Do everything with an understanding of the true purpose for which one desires positive results, not merely for one's own pleasure, liking, or self-indulgence, but acting appropriately according to the circumstances and factors.” – This is the essence of Yonisomanasikara in business management: knowing the cause of a problem and its effect, and how to solve it by applying the Four Noble Truths, using communication (the fourth letter, Communication C, as a guideline).

soulless Non-attachment to self.
In business management and succession.

          Anatta (non-self) is the deepest principle in the Three Characteristics of Existence (impermanence, suffering, and non-self), and it may be a principle that can be applied to family businesses in a way that aligns with normal reality.

1. Attachment : The root of family business problems. In Buddhist philosophy, the suffering of all family business owners often stems from "ego" (the attachment to "I") and "mine" (the attachment to "mine"). These two are the roots of self-attachment or ego, clearly reflected in many forms in the family business world.

Arrogance in family businesses manifests as, "I built this business with my own hands; nobody understands it better than me." This makes it difficult for founders to accept advice, delegate tasks, and pass on the reins. Conversely, possessiveness manifests as, "This business belongs to our family, to our children," leading to a division between "insiders" and "outsiders." This undermines the organization's ability to attract and retain talent and utilize professionals, hindering its ability to adapt and change effectively.

In his book, "The Constitution of Life," the Venerable Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya explains that "Viriyarambha" means diligence, perseverance, striving to avoid evil and do good, persistence, progress, not giving up, and not neglecting one's duties. This diligence requires mental energy, but if that energy is drained away by the protectiveness of the family business owner's "ego" and "possessiveness," there will be insufficient energy left for creativity and development.

2. Anatta in Practice : Managing Organizations with a Leaning and Liberation of the Self. Applying Anatta in business doesn't mean ignoring the business or letting go completely, but rather managing with a broader perspective than just "my self."

His Holiness Somdej Phra Maha Patcharayanmuni (His Eminence Ajahn Chayasaro) explained that "letting go is not neglect." Wise managers will use the principle of non-self (anatta) to manage their affairs with dedication and responsibility, but will not make decisions to protect their own feelings.

In practice, non-self (anatta) manifests itself in organizational cultures where leaders are willing to accept unpleasant truths, dare to adjust their plans when better evidence is available, are happy to give credit for successes to the team, and accept their own mistakes without making excuses.

This is the leader whom the Venerable Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya (Payutto) called possessing "Sappurisadhamma" – the characteristics of a truly virtuous person, which I have written about before.

Thus, using the 6C communication formula, through reflective and understanding listening, unlocks the attachment to the ego through listening (Reflective Listening).

3. Anatta in Business Succession : Passing on “Legacy,” Not “Burden.” One of the most difficult aspects of succeeding a family business is that founders often want to pass on “their vision” rather than the “family business’s values ​​and goals” to their heirs. This is the hidden self (my own) disguised as love – “I did everything for my children,” but in reality, it’s saying, “My children must follow the path I have laid out for me.”

True inheritance requires letting go of attachments to the business and to descendants. This practice of non-self in real life can help reduce conflict and suffering among family members.

The Threefold Integration
Applications for family business management.

When all three aspects of the Three Characteristics of Existence are put together, we see that when they work together as a complete system, this principle is perfect.

Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya explained that ethical values, or values ​​related to mental and physical conduct, and knowledge of the Three Characteristics (impermanence, suffering, and non-self)—that all things are impermanent, uncertain, constantly changing, unstable, and subject to decay and disintegration without waiting for time or listening to anyone, are subject to the law of Anicca (impermanence).

The correct practice is to hasten the response to the causes and conditions, that is, to diligently prevent decline that has not yet occurred, to correct mistakes that have already occurred, to preserve what is good, and to do good so that it may flourish further. (Buddhist Teachings, page 116)

In a business context, wise leaders who see the Three Characteristics of Existence will:

1. Accept that everything changes, and therefore plan to cope with change cautiously rather than resisting it (applying the 6C formula for Change). Change wisely and without recklessness.

2. It is essential to understand that conflict and problems are a part of family business. Therefore, they should be handled with mindfulness and wisdom through communication, not emotion, and using the C4 framework, which includes processes for conflict resolution and conflict management (see Chapter 6, Conflict Management in Family Businesses: The Unavoidable Reality, in the book "6C: The Formula for Failed Family Businesses" (pages 47-53)).

3. Let go of your attachment to your ego, then make decisions for the benefit of the business and all stakeholders. This is represented by C5: Care and Compassion, and the Four Sublime States of Mind (Brahma Vihara 4).

Guidelines Applying the Three Characteristics of Existence (impermanence, suffering, and non-self).
In the life of a family business owner.

1. Create a corporate culture that accepts impermanence : Planning for and preventing decline with prudence. Building a resilient organization must begin with leaders who personally accept impermanence and are prepared and vigilant regardless of what may happen.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Buddhaghosacharya taught about "Dhammanyuta," which means knowing the principles and causes of all things. This is outlined in his book, "Buddhadhamma," and focuses on proactive action, addressing causal factors to prevent future decline, correcting existing mistakes, preserving good qualities, and fostering the growth of good things.

His Holiness Somdej Phra Maha Patcharayanmuni (His Eminence Somdej Acharya Chayasaro) said that the Buddha taught that we must be prepared, which corresponds to the Pali word "appamāda appamāda," meaning mindfulness and readiness to face life's challenges no matter what happens, and to plan accordingly.

Creating a culture of root cause identification and preventative measures, learning from change, having a system for regular monitoring and evaluation, and encouraging employees to offer differing opinions—or managing risks in a way that is prepared for all situations—is about transforming impermanence into a driving force rather than a threat.

2. Create a safe space for everyone. In conflict management, a strong family business accepts that conflict and problems are a part of organizational life, not a sign that "something is wrong." Having mechanisms for constructive conflict management, such as family meetings with clear rules, using external consultants for mediation, and creating safe channels for expressing opinions, is smart conflict resolution. (Using the C4 formula for successful family businesses and conflict management.)

3. Practice ethical values ​​(mental cultivation) to let go regularly to support the value of "action," or if practicing Dharma, especially observing precepts, meditating frequently, it will cultivate the value of mental cultivation.

Conclusion : The Three Characteristics (Tri-lakshana) is a strategic framework.

The Law of the Three Characteristics is not just a principle for spiritual practitioners, but a powerful strategic framework for family business owners in a rapidly changing world.

Those who understand impermanence will not be complacent, complacent, or panicked, and will be prepared for all situations.

Those who understand suffering will not be surprised or alarmed by problems, but will deal with them with wisdom.

Those who understand non-self (anatta) will make decisions for the benefit of the common good, not to protect themselves or their own possessions.

Family business owners can apply the Three Characteristics of Existence by managing their business with dedication and responsibility, being prepared and not negligent, planning carefully, not clinging to outdated methods, not believing themselves to be more important than the business, and remembering that ultimately, everything created is merely a result of natural processes—arising, existing, and ceasing to exist.

But it is the values ​​and legacy that the family has built that will surely endure in the people who benefit from that business. And if everything is done with "prudence," it will be sufficient for the family business to continue sustainably, without necessarily having to be indestructible, or even accepting its failure if everything happened due to certain causes and factors, and we have done our best.





Money & Banking Magazine